March 16 Deadline for Comments on Draft 2008 303(d)/305(b) Integrated Report
A component of AB 885 (see January 11 blog entry), regarding septic and well requirements, involves Section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act, which requires states to develop a list of impaired bodies of water and a priority ranking for addressing the impairments. The 303(d)/305(b) Integrated Report serves a dual purpose because AB 885 regulations require an existing septic within 600 feet of an impaired body of water to have a qualified professional determine whether the septic system is contributing to the impairment. If it does, the owner must retrofit the septic system with supplemental treatment. The approximate cost for a retrofit is $45,000, according to a letter from the Coarsegold Resource Conservation District to the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board. The deadline for comments regarding the bodies of water included in the Draft 2008 303(d)/305(b) Integrated Report is March 16, 2009.
Madera County District 5 Supervisor, Tom Wheeler, would like to ensure that Madera County water bodies are not included in this report. Wheeler said, “If the state is going to require individuals to undergo expensive studies and even more expensive retrofits, it should be held to a high standard of proof that the systems are a likely cause of the water impairment.”
The bodies of water in Madera County currently listed for inclusion are Ash Slough, Berenda Creek Slough, Cottonwood Creek, and Dry Creek. Others listed for inclusion that I will briefly review are Fresno River, Hensley Lake, Lewis Fork, and Willow Creek. To see the complete list and supplemental information, visit: http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/centralvalley/water_issues/tmdl/impaired_waters_list/303d/index.shtml.
Fresno River:
Samples were taken from the Fresno River in Ahwahnee, at Spangle Gold Creek, and in Oakhurst both upstream and downstream of the wastewater treatment facility. The reason Fresno River was included, according to the report, is low dissolved oxygen. The report states that applicable water quality standards are exceeded and a pollutant contributes to or causes the problem. Classifying oxygen as a pollutant appears questionable; especially as low dissolved oxygen cannot be remediated like a metal or toxin. Testing took place from August 2001 to June 2002. The samples that I noted in the report that showed evidence of low dissolved oxygen though were only in August and October of 2001.
According to Professor Steve Blumenshine, CSU Fresno, dissolved oxygen concentrations (mg/L) are affected not only by biological activity, but also by elevation, temperature, and water movement. Thus, the timing of the sampling could be very important. He said, “A good deal of oxygen will have been generated by primary production at the end of a warm and sunny day. Likewise, dissolved oxygen would be rather low just prior to dawn because all of these primary producers will have been respiring (using) oxygen overnight.”
Blumenshine studied Fresno River in 2003 and 2004. The data shows a direct correlation between discharge and dissolved oxygen. This suggests that the findings of low dissolved oxygen were due to low discharge and stagnant water at the sampling sites. Both the CSUF study (2003 and 2004) and the results in the report (2001 and 2002) used SWAMP (Surface Water Ambient Monitoring Program) protocols.
Hensley Lake:
Samples were taken from Hensley Lake at Andy’s Cove, north end of Andy’s Cove, the inflow and outflow areas of Hensley Lake, and near Restroom #7 to the east. Hensley Lake was included in the report due to low dissolved oxygen and pH. The samples that I noted in the report that showed evidence of low dissolved oxygen were in August and October of 2001 (as was Fresno River). Seven of the 13 samples taken exceeded the evaluation objective pH of 8.3. The exceeded results were found in August and October of 2001 as well as June 2002 and ranged between 8.5 and 9.38.
Lewis Fork:
Results in Sugar Pine and Cedar Valley along Lewis Creek exceeded ammonia levels according to the report. The report concludes that the water body-pollutant combination should be included because applicable water quality standards are exceeded and a pollutant contributes to or causes the problem. The results here were unclear to me as in one area it shows 2 of the 4 samples exceeded the guidelines and in another area it shows that 0 of 4 samples exceeded guidelines. Samples were collected August 2001 to October 2001.
Willow Creek:
Willow Creek monitoring occurred from 1986 to 1996. At the North Fork Willow Creek sampling location, below Bass Lake, 2 out of 11 annual maximum temperature values (years 1990 and 1995) exceeded the temperature criteria for steelhead. For the South Fork Willow Creek sampling location, below a Forest Service Road, 8 out of 11 annual maximum temperature values exceeded the criteria for steelhead (PG&E, 2001). The risk assessment approach used by Sullivan et al. (2000) suggests that an upper threshold for the annual maximum of 21.0°C for steelhead will reduce average growth 10% from optimum. The report also included information regarding a Willow Creek study showing reduced surface flow. It also found that water heats up due to solar radiation above the confluence with Whisky Creek. During the study, the measured temperature in this area was 29°C at mid-day. Whisky Creek has a coldwater input and has a healthy trout population (Price, 2002). Including temperature as a pollutant is problematic, especially as temperature cannot be remediated like a metal or toxin.
Other Bodies of Water:
Many other bodies of water are listed and I was unable to locate a reference by county. Thus, I was unable to compile a complete list for our other neighboring counties including Mariposa and Fresno. However, some bodies of water outside of Madera County that I noted include McClure Reservoir in Mariposa County and Millerton Lake in Fresno County. The pollutant listed for both of those bodies of water is mercury. Fish tissue samples were tested and some exceeded the US EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) fish tissue criterion for human health. According to the draft report, fish samples collected were from fish with total lengths greater than 150 mm, which represent fish most commonly caught and consumed by sport fishers and their families. At McClure Reservoir, 3 of 3 samples collected exceeded the criterion. At Millerton Lake, 7 out of 21 samples collected exceeded the criterion. Environmental conditions noted in the report that may account for the findings included mining activity during the Gold Rush era. In these cases, I would not argue about the inclusion of these bodies of water as it is important to address the mercury impairment. However, requiring those with wastewater treatment systems to hire a qualified professional to determine if their system is contributing to the impairment (AB 885 regulation) is unreasonable.
Deadline for Comments Monday
Please view the documents and send comments about the Draft 2008 303(d)/305(b) Report by 5 p.m., March 16, 2009, to Danny McClure, Regional Water Quality Board, Central Valley Region, 11020 Sun Center Drive #200, Rancho Cordova, CA 95670. For questions or additional information, McClure can be contacted at 916-464-4751 or by email at dmcclure@waterboards.ca.gov.
Showing posts with label AB 885. Show all posts
Showing posts with label AB 885. Show all posts
Sunday, March 8, 2009
Sunday, January 11, 2009
Proposed AB 885 Septic and Well Testing Requirements Burdensome and Costly
The California Association of REALTORS® (C.A.R.) released a Red Alert January 7, 2009, regarding regulations for Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems (OWTS) being proposed in AB 885. CA.R. is concerned that, if enacted, these regulations will make it too costly and burdensome to own a property with a septic system. In Madera County, we have almost 20,000 housing units on septic.
The state is in the process of holding several workshops and hearings where members of the public may give written and/or oral input regarding the State Water Board’s proposed regulatory actions and content of the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR). This is your chance to let the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) know that the proposed regulations are too costly and burdensome and that the DEIR falls short of adequately evaluating the true financial impact of the proposed regulations on California homeowners.
District 5 Supervisor Tom Wheeler shared with the Yosemite Gateway Association of REALTORS® on January 8 that he has requested an additional workshop to be held in our area prior to February 9; the deadline set for comments to be provided to the SWRCB regarding the proposed regulations. However, at the time this article was written, there has been no confirmation of an additional hearing to be held in Eastern Madera County.
The Fresno workshop is January 22 at the Fresno Unified School District Board Chamber on 2309 Tulare Street. I’ll be at our C.A.R. meeting in Monterey and will be unable to attend. I would encourage all those that can attend to be there. The remaining workshops are January 27 at 7 p.m. in Santa Rosa, January 28 at 7 p.m. in Eureka, and February 9 at 1:30 p.m. in Sacramento at the Byron Sher Auditorium, Cal EPA Building, on 1001 I Street.
If you plan to attend one of these meetings and provide testimony, be prepared to follow through with providing your written comments and concerns to the SWRCB. Written comments can also be emailed to the SWRCB at AB885@waterboards.ca.gov or mailed to State Water Resources Control Board Division of Water Quality, ATTN: Todd Thompson, P.E., 1001 I Street, 15th Floor, P.O. Box 2231, Sacramento, CA 95812.
The most useful site I’ve found for information on AB 885 is: http://www.swrcb.ca.gov/water_issues/programs/septic_tanks/.
C.A.R. is opposing the current draft of the proposed regulations for many reasons.
• The cost of achieving compliance is too burdensome and costly and hurts housing affordability.
• Groundwater testing and routine inspections will be required whether there is evidence of septic-related problems or not, adding an unnecessary cost burden to property owners—many of whom are low income.
• The separation to groundwater standard and loss of sidewall infiltration will require new and existing homebuyers to install tremendously expensive “alternative systems” if they are even locally allowed.
• The regulations need to allow for an effective, pragmatic variance process, where local government regulators can make site-specific exceptions to the regulations and determinations of “functional equivalency” for local conditions.
• The owners of existing septic systems with supplemental treatment systems will now be required to maintain and transfer technical documents at point of sale. This is a problem because thousands of systems would already be out of compliance due to lost or misplaced documents and real estate professionals will be required to purchase additional lost instrument bonds and will be exposed to increased liability.
• The requirement to install groundwater-monitoring wells for new systems is too costly and will prevent building on otherwise usable lots.
• The groundwater testing requirements are overkill. Testing should be changed to fecal and bacteria sampling, which shows a direct nexus to a failing system.
C.A.R. has the following concerns about the DEIR.
• The DEIR does not give adequate proof that all septic systems are causing water quality problems.
• The DEIR does not adequately consider the true financial impact of these regulations on property owners, especially those who are low income.
• The DEIR does not adequately address the impact of the new disclosure responsibility, increased liability exposure, and added uncertainty on real estate transactions created by the proposed regulations.
• The DEIR failed to adequately address funding options available for low-income property owners to allow them to comply with the proposed regulations. Instead, it asks this population to rely on a fund which may not have enough money available to help all those who will need it.
• The DEIR failed to recognize that the proposed regulations will, in fact, curtail the ability for property owners to develop their lots and therefore will slow or stop growth in some areas. The report also failed to evaluate the impact of the proposed regulations on the ability for local governments to achieve the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) goals.
• The DEIR failed to quantify and analyze the increased green house gas (GHG) emissions that will be generated from all the well testing, tank inspections, and septic waste hauling, contrary to AB 32.
The state is in the process of holding several workshops and hearings where members of the public may give written and/or oral input regarding the State Water Board’s proposed regulatory actions and content of the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR). This is your chance to let the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) know that the proposed regulations are too costly and burdensome and that the DEIR falls short of adequately evaluating the true financial impact of the proposed regulations on California homeowners.
District 5 Supervisor Tom Wheeler shared with the Yosemite Gateway Association of REALTORS® on January 8 that he has requested an additional workshop to be held in our area prior to February 9; the deadline set for comments to be provided to the SWRCB regarding the proposed regulations. However, at the time this article was written, there has been no confirmation of an additional hearing to be held in Eastern Madera County.
The Fresno workshop is January 22 at the Fresno Unified School District Board Chamber on 2309 Tulare Street. I’ll be at our C.A.R. meeting in Monterey and will be unable to attend. I would encourage all those that can attend to be there. The remaining workshops are January 27 at 7 p.m. in Santa Rosa, January 28 at 7 p.m. in Eureka, and February 9 at 1:30 p.m. in Sacramento at the Byron Sher Auditorium, Cal EPA Building, on 1001 I Street.
If you plan to attend one of these meetings and provide testimony, be prepared to follow through with providing your written comments and concerns to the SWRCB. Written comments can also be emailed to the SWRCB at AB885@waterboards.ca.gov or mailed to State Water Resources Control Board Division of Water Quality, ATTN: Todd Thompson, P.E., 1001 I Street, 15th Floor, P.O. Box 2231, Sacramento, CA 95812.
The most useful site I’ve found for information on AB 885 is: http://www.swrcb.ca.gov/water_issues/programs/septic_tanks/.
C.A.R. is opposing the current draft of the proposed regulations for many reasons.
• The cost of achieving compliance is too burdensome and costly and hurts housing affordability.
• Groundwater testing and routine inspections will be required whether there is evidence of septic-related problems or not, adding an unnecessary cost burden to property owners—many of whom are low income.
• The separation to groundwater standard and loss of sidewall infiltration will require new and existing homebuyers to install tremendously expensive “alternative systems” if they are even locally allowed.
• The regulations need to allow for an effective, pragmatic variance process, where local government regulators can make site-specific exceptions to the regulations and determinations of “functional equivalency” for local conditions.
• The owners of existing septic systems with supplemental treatment systems will now be required to maintain and transfer technical documents at point of sale. This is a problem because thousands of systems would already be out of compliance due to lost or misplaced documents and real estate professionals will be required to purchase additional lost instrument bonds and will be exposed to increased liability.
• The requirement to install groundwater-monitoring wells for new systems is too costly and will prevent building on otherwise usable lots.
• The groundwater testing requirements are overkill. Testing should be changed to fecal and bacteria sampling, which shows a direct nexus to a failing system.
C.A.R. has the following concerns about the DEIR.
• The DEIR does not give adequate proof that all septic systems are causing water quality problems.
• The DEIR does not adequately consider the true financial impact of these regulations on property owners, especially those who are low income.
• The DEIR does not adequately address the impact of the new disclosure responsibility, increased liability exposure, and added uncertainty on real estate transactions created by the proposed regulations.
• The DEIR failed to adequately address funding options available for low-income property owners to allow them to comply with the proposed regulations. Instead, it asks this population to rely on a fund which may not have enough money available to help all those who will need it.
• The DEIR failed to recognize that the proposed regulations will, in fact, curtail the ability for property owners to develop their lots and therefore will slow or stop growth in some areas. The report also failed to evaluate the impact of the proposed regulations on the ability for local governments to achieve the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) goals.
• The DEIR failed to quantify and analyze the increased green house gas (GHG) emissions that will be generated from all the well testing, tank inspections, and septic waste hauling, contrary to AB 32.
Labels:
AB 885,
Beverly Scott,
oakhurst,
real estate,
septic,
Tom Wheeler,
well,
yosemite
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
